Pet health insurance – types, benefits, and costs at a glance (part 2 of 3)

Pet insurance policies vary significantly in terms of coverage, cost, and target audience. Depending on the type of animal, its health, and your budget, simple surgical insurance or comprehensive full coverage may be appropriate. In this second part of our three-part article series "Pet Insurance," you will get an overview of the most important types of insurance and their differences in coverage.

INHALT
What types of insurance are there? The differences in the scope of services What are the typical exclusions? How much does pet health insurance cost? What factors influence the insurance premium? Exemplary cost comparisons Further articles in the series "Pet health insurance"
What types of insurance are there?

There are two main types of pet health insurance: surgery insurance and comprehensive insurance. Some providers supplement these options with additional services that can be selected individually.

Surgery insurance

Surgery insurance covers the costs of surgical procedures performed under anesthesia. This includes the cost of the operation itself and often also the anesthesia, surgical materials, and inpatient aftercare. Some tariffs also include preliminary examinations or follow-up checks. It offers cost-effective basic protection, but only covers surgical procedures. Treatments that do not involve surgery – such as for chronic illnesses or routine examinations – are not insured.

Comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive insurance covers almost all medically necessary treatments – both after accidents and in the event of illness. It typically includes:

  • Surgery, including anesthesia and hospital stay
  • Outpatient treatments and aftercare
  • Diagnostics, such as laboratory tests, X-rays, ultrasounds, CT or MRI scans
  • Medication, including for long-term therapies
  • Some preventive services, such as vaccinations, worming, and health checks
  • Dental treatments, such as tartar removal, tooth preservation, or tooth extractions
  • Coverage abroad, limited in time, usually throughout the EU

The scope of benefits varies depending on the provider. Some plans also include alternative therapies such as physiotherapy or homeopathy.

As the cover is much more comprehensive, the monthly premiums are higher than for surgical insurance. In return, almost all veterinary services are covered.

Supplementary and combination plans

Some insurers offer optional supplementary modules or combination products, for example:

  • Additional dental services for extensive dental treatment
  • Preventive care packages for vaccinations, deworming, or check-ups
  • Coverage abroad for traveling with animals
  • Combined insurance policies that combine health and liability coverage, for example for dogs or horses

Such tariffs offer flexibility, but increase the monthly premium.

The differences in the scope of services

Choosing the right type of insurance depends largely on which services are covered in an emergency. Some typical differences between surgical and comprehensive insurance are the following differences in the scope of services:

Surgery insurance

  • Surgery including anesthesia
  • (Pre- and post-operative care: partial)
  • (Diagnostics, e.g., laboratory, X-ray: partial)
  • (Medication: partial)
  • (Inpatient stays: partial)
  • Dental surgery
  • (Coverage abroad: partial)
  • (Alternative therapies: partial)

Comprehensive insurance

  • Surgery including anesthesia
  • Pre- and post-operative care
  • Outpatient treatments
  • Diagnostics, e.g., laboratory tests, X-rays
  • Medication
  • Inpatient stays
  • (Preventive care, e.g., vaccinations, worming: partial)
  • Dental surgery
  • (Dental treatment: partial)
  • (Coverage abroad: partial)
  • (Alternative healing methods: partial)

The following examples illustrate that comprehensive insurance offers significant added value not only in rare emergencies, but also in the case of frequent illnesses:

Surgery insurance

  • Cruciate ligament rupture in dogs, approx. $3,000–$4,000, surgery and aftercare
  • Stomach torsion in a dog, approx. €3,000–5,000
  • Colic surgery in a horse, €12,000–14,000

Comprehensive insurance

  • Cruciate ligament rupture in dogs, approx. $3,000–4,000
  • Stomach torsion in dogs, approx. $3,000–5,000
  • (Vaccinations, preventive care, $65–$180 annually: partial coverage)
  • Chronic skin disease, $300–$800 annually
  • (Dental treatment for cats, $400–$1,000: partial coverage)
  • Colic surgery for horses, €12,000–14,000
  • (Vaccinations/preventive care for horses, $150–500 annually: partial)

(Costs: as of 2025)

What are the typical exclusions?

Regardless of the tariff, certain exclusions or restrictions apply:

  • Pre-existing conditions of the animal prior to conclusion of the contract
  • Hereditary or breeding diseases, unless expressly included
  • Non-medically necessary procedures, such as castration without indication or cosmetic surgery
  • Birth and pregnancy costs, only included in special tariffs
  • Alternative therapies, unless expressly agreed

These points should be carefully reviewed when concluding the contract, as they greatly influence the actual benefits of the insurance.

How much does pet health insurance cost?

Veterinary costs are not incurred because veterinarians are "too expensive," but because modern veterinary medicine now often offers the same standard of quality as human medicine.

High-quality treatment requires well-trained specialists, modern equipment such as X-ray, CT, MRI, ultrasound, or endoscopy, and effective medications, which are costly to manufacture and use. The German Veterinary Fee Schedule (GOT) also stipulates binding minimum prices so that veterinary services can be provided economically.

Against this background, pet health insurance is not a luxury expense, but a tool for making the financial burden of necessary medical care more predictable. Interestingly, studies show that pet owners in many countries spend significantly more money on food, toys, grooming products, or training than on health insurance. According to the study "Pets in Australia – A national survey of pets and people" (Animal Medicines Australia, 2022), the average monthly expenses amount to just under €100, of which:

  • Food: approximately €60
  • Care and accessories: approximately €25
  • Training and dog school: approximately €15

Insurance, on the other hand, is available for a fifth of the cost of what you already spend on your pet each month.

Average costs by animal type

The amount of insurance premiums depends on several factors—primarily the type of animal, age, breed, health status, scope of insurance, and provider. The following overview shows typical price ranges for common rates (as of 2025, rounded average values from consumer portals and comparison sites):

Dog

  • Surgery insurance: approximately $20 to $35 per month
  • Comprehensive insurance: approximately €40 to €70 per month

Depending on breed and age, larger or older dogs are more expensive.

Cat

  • Surgery insurance: approx. €10 to €25 per month
  • Comprehensive insurance: approx. €25 to €45 per month

Indoor cats are usually cheaper than outdoor cats.

Horse

  • Surgery insurance: approx. €35 to €60 per month
  • Comprehensive insurance: approx. €80 to €150 per month

Depending on the type of use, age, and scope of coverage

These figures provide a general framework; actual premiums may vary individually. Premiums increase significantly, especially for older animals or breeds with a higher risk, such as hip dysplasia in large dogs.

What factors influence the insurance premium?

The insurance premium is determined by various parameters:

  • Animal species and breed: Larger animals and certain breeds, such as French bulldogs or German shepherds, statistically incur higher veterinary costs.
  • Age: The older the animal is when the policy is taken out, the higher the risk—and therefore the higher the premium
  • Health status: Pre-existing conditions may be excluded from insurance coverage or subject to higher premiums
  • Scope of coverage: Comprehensive insurance costs more than pure surgery rates
  • Deductible: An agreed deductible, for example 10 to 20 percent, reduces the monthly premium
  • Maximum coverage limit: Some providers limit the annual reimbursement, for example, to $3,000 to $5,000, while others pay unlimited amounts
  • GOT reimbursement rate: Plans that reimburse 3 or 4 times the rate of the fee schedule for veterinarians are more expensive but offer more security in an emergency

These factors should be taken into account when choosing a tariff in order to achieve a good balance between premium and benefits.

Exemplary cost comparisons

The following examples show how much insurance can pay off in an emergency:

Dog, cruciate ligament rupture

  • Costs without insurance: approx. €3,000
  • Co-payment with surgery insurance: approx. €300 to €600 (depending on the tariff)
  • Co-payment with comprehensive insurance: €0 to €300

Cat, tumor surgery

  • Costs without insurance: approx. €1,800
  • Co-payment with surgical insurance: approx. €200 to €400
  • Co-payment with comprehensive insurance: €0 to €200

Horse, colic surgery

  • Costs without insurance: approx. €12,000 to €14,000
  • Co-payment with surgical insurance: approx. €500 to €1,000
  • Co-payment with comprehensive insurance: €0 to €500

Even a single one of these cases can exceed the annual or multi-year premiums of an insurance policy. This illustrates that pet health insurance is not primarily intended to save on regular expenses, but to cover existential cost risks.

The monthly premiums for pet health insurance are manageable, especially in relation to the potential treatment costs and everyday expenses that pet owners have anyway.

While high-quality food, care products, and leisure activities are taken for granted, financial protection in the event of illness is often underestimated. Pet health insurance not only provides financial security, but also predictability—and ensures that the animal's health comes first in an emergency.

Further articles in the series "Pet health insurance"

In the first part, we show you why pet health insurance is worthwhile.

  • When love suddenly becomes expensive – why insurance for your pet is so important

In the third part, you will learn what to look for when choosing pet health insurance, which benefits are really important, and how you can compare different rates.

  • Finding the right rate – what you should look out for and how to compare fairly

So that you end up making the decision that feels right – for you and for your pet.