When appearance becomes suffering – torture breeding

Some breeds that have been bred by humans to achieve a desired appearance suffer from serious health problems: breathing difficulties, joint damage, eye problems, or limited ability to communicate – the list of diseases and affected animal breeds is long. But what exactly is torture breeding?

INHALT
Definition Torture breeding characteristics in dogs and cats Torture breeding characteristics in dogs Torture breeding characteristics in cats Torture breeding characteristics in horses Torture breeding characteristics in rabbits Torture breeding characteristics in birds What can I do myself?
Definition

Torture breeding refers to individual animals that have been bred to have characteristics that are highly pronounced and can cause pain, suffering, or distress. Torture breeding is prohibited under Section 11b of the German Animal Welfare Act.

The most common torture breeding characteristics, their effects on health, and the animal breeds affected are described in the following sections.

Torture breeding characteristics in dogs and cats

Short head (=brachycephaly)

Brachycephalic breeds are affected by a lot of health problems caused by their special skull shape. The most common problems include (see also article Brachycephalic syndrome):

  • Brachycephalic animals have difficulties in breathing, which manifests itself in snoring, wheezing, and even severe respiratory distress. The resulting lack of oxygen leads to organ damage, low stamina, and restricted play and social behavior.
  • Due to their shortened snout, they lack the cooling effect when breathing in. The additional difficulty in panting disrupts thermoregulation. As a result, brachycephalic animals overheat quickly.
  • Excessive skin folds lead to skin inflammation and fungal diseases.
  • The narrowing of the tear duct leads to dry eyes. The outward flow of tears causes skin inflammation.
  • Impaired facial expressions lead to limited social communication.
  • The protruding eyes lead to eye injuries and dryness, visual impairment, nictitating membrane prolapse (see corresponding article), and drooping eyelids (see below).
  • Malformations of the jaw and teeth lead to problems with eating and gastrointestinal disorders, including vomiting.
  • The rounded and malformed skull leads to difficult births, hydrocephalus, painful pressure on the brain, and tumors. An open gap between the skull plates poses a risk of brain injury.
  • The narrowing of the inner ear leads to the accumulation of secretions and can result in hearing loss.

Affected dog breeds: French, English, and American Bulldogs, Boxers, Chihuahuas, Pugs, Pekingese, King Charles Spaniels, Shih Tzus, Toy Spaniels, Mastiffs

Affected cat breeds: Persian, Exotic, and British Shorthair

Short tail or tailless

A short tail is associated with various spinal deformities. This can lead to neurological disorders in the hindquarters. These can include loss of sensation, paralysis of the hind limbs, and urinary and fecal incontinence. Social communication is also impaired without a tail. Cats are also unable to balance themselves.

Affected dog breeds: French and English Bulldogs, Dachshunds, Bobtails, Cocker Spaniels, Entlebucher Mountain Dogs, Rottweilers, Pugs

Affected cat breeds: Manx, Cymric, Japanese and Kurilian Bobtail

Hairlessness

Hairlessness disrupts thermoregulation and leaves the skin unprotected. This can lead to skin problems, allergies, sunburn, and skin cancer. Cats also experience skin thickening, inflammation, and fungal infections in skin folds. Their social communication is disrupted by hairlessness. The absence of tactile hairs also impairs their sense of touch.

Affected dog breeds: Chinese Crested Dog, Mexican and Peruvian Hairless Dog, French Bulldog (hairless), American Hairless Terrier

Affected cat breeds: Sphynx, Devon Rex, Lykoi

Dwarfism

Shortened limbs in relation to a long body can be accompanied by malformations of the intervertebral discs and slipped discs.

In dogs, the following also occur:

  • Orthopedic problems due to bow legs
  • Slow or lack of growth in puppies
  • Protruding lower jaw
  • Teeth that are close together
  • Short head (see above)
  • Curvature of the spine
  • Heart problems
  • Reduced bone density

Affected dog breeds: Basset, Dachshund, Beagle, Corgis, English Bulldog

In cats, limited mobility can lead to obesity, arthritis, and osteoarthritis. Difficult births, spinal curvature, and funnel chest also occur. The life expectancy is greatly reduced.

Affected cat breeds: Munchkin, Minuet, Minskin

Dilute gene

The dilute gene is a genetic color variation that causes the coat color to lighten. It causes the melanin (=color pigment) in the hair to clump together, making the coat appear lighter. This results in colors such as blue, silver, or champagne. The dilute gene can be associated with the hereditary disease color mutant alopecia (CDA), which causes hair loss, itching, and skin inflammation. In Weimaraners, the dilute gene is permitted in the breeding standard, as it does not appear to have any negative effects on this breed.

Affected dog breeds: Chihuahua, Doberman, Dachshund, French Bulldog, Labrador Retriever

Affected cat breeds: Chartreux, Russian Blue


Brachycephalic dog with prolapsed nictitating membrane
Brachycephalic dog with prolapsed nictitating membrane
Torture breeding characteristics in dogs

Chiari malformation and syringomyelia

Chiari malformation is a skull malformation at the junction of the skull and cervical spine that occurs in small, brachycephalic dogs, particularly in the majority of Cavalier King Charles Spaniels. The altered skull bones and a thickening of the meninges cause the posterior cranial fossa to become overcrowded. This puts pressure on the cerebellum and brain stem. This can cause part of the cerebellum to fall into or through the foramen magnum into the spinal canal. This disrupts the flow of cerebrospinal fluid, which then accumulates in the cavities of the brain and spinal cord. This results in hydrocephalus and syringomyelia (=formation of cavities in the spinal cord). Affected dogs experience scratching and pain attacks as well as sensitivity to touch in the neck area. As the disease progresses, neurological disorders occur, which can lead to partial paralysis of the limbs up to complete paralysis of all four limbs.

Affected breeds: Cavalier King Charles Spaniel, Affenpinscher, Griffon Bruxellois

Hip joint malformation

Hip joint dysplasia (see corresponding article) leads to hip joint inflammation and osteoarthritis and is accompanied by pain.

Affected breeds: German Shepherd, Bernese Mountain Dog, Golden Retriever, Rottweiler

Malposition of the eyelids

Drooping eyelids (see corresponding article) can lead to conjunctivitis and constant eye discharge.

Affected breeds: Neapolitan Mastiff, Great Dane, Mastiff, Basset, Spaniels, Newfoundland, Boxer, Pug

Rolled eyelids (see corresponding article) are associated with conjunctival and corneal inflammation, corneal ulcers, and hypersensitivity to light.

Affected breeds: Rottweiler, Golden Retriever, Chow Chow, Shar Pei

Cysts on the back

Some deep cysts cause pain, paralysis of the hind legs, and even inflammation of the meninges and spinal cord.

Affected breeds: Rhodesian and Thai Ridgeback

Merle factor

The merle factor is a genetic variation in coat color. It causes irregular, mottled patches in the dark base color on a lighter background. This is accompanied by malformations of the eyes and inner ear, deafness, and resulting social behavior problems and developmental disorders.

Affected breeds: Collie, Border Collie, Shetland Sheepdog, Welsh Corgi Cardigan, Australian Shepherd, Dachshund, Dunker, Bergamasker Shepherd Dog, Berger des Pyrénées, Berger de Beauce, Mudi, Old German Shepherd Dog, Catahoula Leopard Dog, Pomeranian, Chihuahua, French Bulldog (color bully), Pug (colored pug), Aussiedoodle, Aussiedor

Grey Collie Syndrome

Grey Collie Syndrome is a genetic disorder characterized by a silver-gray discoloration of the coat. It is associated with severe problems in the formation of white blood cells. Their number drops sharply at regular intervals. Affected collies are therefore susceptible to infections. This leads to frequent inflammation of the gums and diarrhea. Antibiotics must be administered on a permanent basis to protect against infections. The dogs often die at an early age.

Various Collie breeding lines are affected.

Dalmatian coat color

In addition to the typical coat coloration of Dalmatians, deafness is also inherited. In these dogs, the migration of pigment cells to the inner ear is disrupted. However, these cells are necessary in the hair cells of the inner ear to convert sound waves into nerve impulses. Almost ten percent of Dalmatians suffer from hearing impairment. Two percent are deaf in both ears. In the US, where different breeding standards apply, as many as 22 percent of Dalmatians are deaf in one ear and eight percent in both ears. Dalmatians with a lot of white in their coat and blue eyes are particularly affected.

In addition, Dalmatians lack an enzyme for breaking down uric acid. They are therefore prone to developing urinary stones.

Tea cup breeds

Tea cups are small breeds that are created through the selective breeding of small and weak animals. The size difference between the mother and her puppies can lead to problems during birth, particularly with hydrocephalus puppies. The large eyes in a small face can cause corneal damage and eye infections.

Affected breeds: Chihuahua, Miniature Pinscher, Yorkshire Terrier, Toy Poodle

Gigantism / Giantism

Gigantism is a genetic growth disorder that leads to excessive production of growth hormones. The resulting extremely large dogs often suffer from osteoarthritis, elbow or hip joint dysplasia (see corresponding articles) due to the high load on their bones and joints. They are also prone to bone tumors. Their deep chest puts them at high risk of gastric torsion (see corresponding article). Giant dogs age earlier and have a significantly shorter life expectancy than smaller breeds.

Affected breeds: St. Bernard, Great Dane, Irish Wolfhound, Mastiff

Excessive skin folds

Wrinkle formation is associated with a tendency to skin inflammation with hair loss, pustules, skin redness, skin keratinization, and severe itching. It can also lead to mucinosis, a disease that causes the skin to become doughy in consistency.

Affected breeds: Shar Pei, Basset, Bloodhound, Pekingese, Toy Spaniel

Torture breeding characteristics in cats

Folded ears

Folded ears are associated with several health problems. These include:

  • Defective bone development
  • Severe bone and cartilage malformations
  • Malformed limbs and tail
  • Movement disorders
  • Arthritis
  • Loss of hearing
  • Problems with social communication due to ear position

Affected breeds: Scottish Fold, Highland Fold, American Curl, Poodle cats

Color gene White

In white cats, deafness is also inherited with the color gene. Some white cats lack the so-called Corti organ in the inner ear. This is necessary for processing acoustic signals. Deafness is particularly common in white cats with blue eyes. Approximately 60 to 80 percent of those with two blue eyes are deaf.

Affected breeds: Turkish Angora, Persian, Maine Coon, British Shorthair, Russian White

White cat with blue eyes
White cats with blue eyes are often deaf.
Torture breeding characteristics in horses

Color variations

The dilute gene also causes a lightening of the coat in horses. The resulting color variations, cremello, perlino, and smoky cream, have eyes and skin that are more sensitive to UV light. They quickly get sunburned and have more frequent skin problems such as dry skin, skin infections, or eczema. Palominos and cremellos are also more frequently affected by squamous cell carcinoma (=skin cancer).

Color breeding on Splashed white causes irregular white markings on the head, legs, and belly. These horses can be deaf if splashed white is very pronounced.

Silver-colored horses may have eye malformations that can manifest as bulging eyeballs and cysts.

Lavender Foal Syndrome (LFS) causes various neurological disorders and overstretched joints in lavender-colored (light gray-brown) Arabian thoroughbred horses. Affected foals die shortly after birth or have to be euthanized.

Unphysiological anatomy

Arabian horses with extremely concave noses have difficulties in breathing due to the narrowness of their nasal passages and therefore show performance limitations. They are also more susceptible to respiratory infections because the natural cleansing process of the respiratory tract is impaired.

In Tennessee Walker horses, the small, delicate head can lead to a less stable head-neck connection. This can affect their balance.

Miniature horses and ponies

Miniature horses and ponies have a range of health problems. Their deformed bodies, with spherical heads, shortened necks and/or chests, enlarged joints, and bent front legs, cause them severe pain in some cases. The small skull causes crowding of the teeth and malocclusion. This leads to problems with eating. In addition, cleft palates occur, resulting in breathing problems. Miniature horses tend to be overweight. This can lead to secondary diseases such as laminitis, hyperlipidemia syndrome, and equine metabolic syndrome (see corresponding articles).

Torture breeding characteristics in rabbits

Rabbits with very drooping ears are prone to ear infections, deafness, and have a restricted field of vision. This affects lop-eared rabbits, for example.

In large rabbit breeds, the high weight leads to sole ulcers, circulatory disorders, and osteoarthritis. German Giants are affected, for example.

In long-haired breeds, the thick coat causes heat build-up, restricted movement and gastrointestinal disorders due to hair being swallowed. Angora rabbits are affected by this, for example.

Torture breeding characteristics in birds

Birds with an extra-long neck or featherless or particularly heavily feathered body parts can suffer from balance disorders, inability to fly, and impaired vision. This affects canaries, for example.

In pouter pigeons, the crop can become inflamed.

What can I do myself?

Buyer demand has a strong influence on animal breeding. Desired physical characteristics have been bred into animals, leading to significant health problems. The extreme short-headedness of many dog breeds is a prime example. Counteract these trends. When making your purchase decision, be sure to prioritize the welfare and health of the animal. Don't just think about its appearance. Find out more, for example, from the database of the Qualzucht-Evidenz Netzwerk (QUEN) at https://qualzucht-datenbank.eu/.

Numerous advertisers still use supposedly cute-looking torture breeds as advertising faces. Be critical of the public portrayal of animals that may be suffering: don't leave any likes and think carefully about which animals you want to show on your social media.

If you own an animal of a torture breed, pay particular attention to specific health problems. Your veterinarian will be happy to advise you on breed-specific preventive care. You can make an appointment directly via petsXL.